In addition, defeasible reasoning can be used to illuminate moral and legal dilemmas, cases in which general rules come into conflict see horty 1994, 2003. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications springer theses naeem khalid janjua on. Automated negotiation, software agent, defeasible logic, statecharts. We will also discuss briey in this paper how to extend delp for considering default negation. Xml tree editor xmltreeedit displays xml files as tree views and allows basic operations. Inspired by legal reasoning, this paper presents a semantics and proof theory of a system for defeasible argumentation. The work reported here introduces defeasible logic programming delp, a formalism that combines results of logic programming and defeasible. Conflicts between arguments are decided with the help of priorities on the rules. This paper relates the defeasible logic programming delp framework and its semantics sem delp to classical logic programming frameworks. On the accrual of arguments in defeasible logic programming. Read a defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications by naeem khalid janjua available from rakuten kobo.
The conditions are essentially inference rules phrased as conditions on proofs. Defeasible logic programming, or delp for short, provides a computational reasoning system that uses an argumentation engine to obtain answers from a knowledge base represented using a logic programming language extended with defeasible rules that stem from the work reported in simari and simari and loui. Defeasible logic, originally created by donald nute with a particular concern about efficiency and implementation, is a simple and efficient rule based nonmonotonic formalism. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications ebook by naeem khalid janjua. Formal logic softwareanalysisprogramming language s ebay. Community contributions have added several interfaces and the constraint clp libraries. As a company, entertron was first to offer free plc programming software way back in 1984. Argument construction and reinstatement in logics for. Pdf an argumentative approach to assessing safety in. Defeasible logic and its variants are an important family of defeasible reasoning methods. Over the year the logic has been developed and extended, and several variants have been proposed.
It discusses in depth one particular approach, default logic, including properties, semantics and computational models. Acknowledgements my heartfelt gratitude goes to my supervisors dr. This is possible through a natural extension of the declarative and procedural semantics of. During the process of deduction, the strict rules are always applied, while a defeasible rule can be applied only if no defeater. From theory to systems and applications policybased computing. In contrast to this, in normal logic programming nlp, there is only one kind. A temporal logic program is a set of basic temporal facts and strict or.
This is possible through a natural extension of the declarative and procedural semantics of horn clauses. And given the low computational complexity of defeasible logic programming, these strategies can also be executed in real time. Defeasible reasoning stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Codifying knowledge by means of a delp program provides a good tradeo. Querying a defeasible logic program is done by issuing the request. Defeasible reasoning and logic programming springerlink. In contrast with most other nonmonotonic logics, defeasible logic has linear complexity, allowing delores to.
A formal approach to negotiating agents development. Automating defeasible reasoning with logic programming derelop. Major logic programming language families include prolog, answer set programming asp and datalog. Read a defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications by naeem khalid janjua available from rakuten kobo. Defeasible reasoning is a particular kind of nondemonstrative reasoning, where the reasoning does not produce a full, complete, or final demonstration of a claim, i.
In such cases it is necessary to make plausible assumptions, which in default reasoning are based on default rules. It usually occurs when a rule is given, but there may be specific exceptions to the rule, or subclasses that are subject to a different rule. In delp, we distinguish between two different sorts of rules. Defeasible logic programming, or delp for short, provides a computational reasoning system that uses an argumentation engine to obtain answers from a knowledge base represented using a logic programming language extended with defeasible rules that stem from the work reported in simari 1989 and simari and loui 1992. Download ladder logic programming software for free windows.
Defeasible logic is a nonmonotonic logic proposed by donald nute to formalize defeasible reasoning. In this paper we establish close links to known semantics of logic programs. Yap contributes to this area by providing a dynamic indexing mechanism, or justintime indexer. Defeasible logic on an embedded microcontroller michael a. The resulting approach is suitable for representing agents knowledge and for providing an argumentation based reasoning mechanism to agents. In this paper we outline a method for safety assessment of medical devices based on defeasible logic programming delp, which provides an argumentative framework for reasoning with uncertain and. In contrast with most other nonmonotonic logics, defeasible logic has linear complexity, allowing delores to execute large theories very quickly. An inference engine for crprolog debugging asp programs by means of asp a. Argumentbased extended logic programming with defeasible. The language of the ps logic extends that of standard logic programming by allowing strong or classical negation in addition to the usual weak negation or negation by failure, and by allowing rules to be formed through defeasible as well as strict implication. Drnegotiate a system for automated agent negotiation. A priority ordering over the defeasible rules and the defeaters can be given. Embedding defeasible logic into logic programming delab. An argumentative approach to assessing safety in medical.
Deloress algorithm extends to general defeasible theories through the use of a pre. Relating defeasible and normal logic programming through. A in these rules are considered to represent classical negation. An argumentation theoretic foundation of logic programming.
This webpage provides a web service for defeasible logic programming delp. Software ladder logic, logic programming, programing. A defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications. Although defeasible logic is certainly not an enduser language but rather a developers one, it could provide a foundation for designing userfriendly interfaces for negotiation strategy specification. Third, a important contribution of the yap system has been the integration of both orparallelism and tabling in a single logic programming system. This paper relates the defeasible logic programming delp framework and its semantics to classical logic programming frameworks. Of course, it would be best if we could have a probabilistic logic, where every statement has an attached probability.
Spindle is a logic reasoner that can be used to compute the consequence of defeasible logic theories in an efficient manner. Invited talkscompetition logic programming and nonmonotonic reasoning. Assistant research engineer, centre for computational law. This book constitutes the refereed proceedings of the 8th international conference on logic programming and nonmonotonic reasoning, lpnmr 2005, held in diamante, italy in september 2005. Swiprolog theory and practice of logic programming. This contrasts markedly with most other propositional nonmonotonic logics, in which inference is intractable. Defeasible logic is a system of reasoning in which rules have exceptions, and when rules con. Defeasible logic versus logic programming without negation. So far no relationship has been established between defeasible logic and mainstream nonmonotonic reasoning approaches. With the click of a button, you can build complex control algorithms, diagnose problems and run realtime or simulated operational data to evaluate the performance of a control sequence. Logic programming is a programming paradigm which is largely based on formal logic.
We show that inference in the propositional form of the logic can be performed in linear time. Over 20 years of software engineering experience through all phases of the sdlc. In handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming, volume 3. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications.
Distributed and flexible workflow coordination using delp has been influenced by a model of the argumentative approach of delp theorists garcia and simari 2004. Arguments are expressed in a logicprogramming language with both weak and strong negation. See more ideas about logic programming, programming and learn to speak korean. In lpwnf 5, a logic program consists of a set of rules of the form. Propositional defeasible logic has linear complexity theory. In particular, we give a translation of a defeasible theory d into a metaprogram pd. Pdf an argumentative approach to assessing safety in medical. Embedding defeasible logic into logic programming core. Jul 19, 2012 entertron reintroduces the concept of free plc programming software.
I present an alternative account of defeasible entailment and show how logic programming offers a paradigm in which the distinction can be captured, allowing for the modeling of a larger range of types of defeat. Research engineerscientist, symbolic ai, sol job with. Hoare logic kripke structures modal mucalculus dynamic logic deontic, temporal, and epistemic modals situation calculus process calculi multivalent logics defeasible logic bdi abductive logic flogic intuitionistic nonmonotonic logics skolemization. A novel argumentation semantics of defeasible logic programs delp is presented. Defeasible reasoning is a simple but efficient approach to nonmonotonic reasoning that has recently attracted considerable interest and that has found various. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support. In philosophical logic, defeasible reasoning is a kind of reasoning that is rationally compelling, though not deductively valid. Delp stands for defeasible logic programming, a knowledge representation language, where defeasible and non defeasible rules can be expressed. In defeasible logic, there are three different types of propositions. Delores defeasible logic reasoning system is a forwardchaining reasoning engine for defeasible logic, a lessexpressive but more efficient nonmonotonic logic. Delp is a formalism that combines logic programming with defeasible argumentation. Defeasible logic programming an argumentative approach. Lee a defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications por naeem khalid janjua disponible en rakuten kobo. It also gives an overview of other ideas and approaches.
From systems and applications to theory the first answer set programming system competition technical papers crmodels. Defeasible logic is a rulebased nonmonotonic logic, with both strict and defeasible rules, and a priority relation on rules. Research engineerscientist, symbolic ai, sol in computer science, research related with singapore management university. Delores is a forwardchaining reasoning engine for defeasible logic, an inexpressive but efficient nonmonotonic logic. Second, most logic programming systems have a rather limited indexing algorithm. The ontology layer of the semantic web is now mature enough i.
A defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications springer theses naeem khalid janjua on. The 25 revised full papers, 16 revised for the system and application tracks presented together with 3. Download ladder logic programming software for free. Deliberative stock market agents using jinni and defeasible logic programming esaw00 april 25, 2000. It is based on the concept of a derivation or proof in d f,r. They have analyzed various aspects of the argumentative approach on delp in their paper. Embedding defeasible logic programs into generalized logic. Arguments are expressed in a logic programming language with both weak and strong negation. Swiprolog is neither a commercial prolog system nor a purely academic enterprise, but increasingly a community project. Defeasible logic programming an argumentative approach 97 knowledge. Defeasible logic programming and belief revision uns. Delores defeasible logic reasoning system a reasoning engine by tristan miller.
Theory and practice of logic programming most cited. Guido governatori, who provided me with guidance, insights and their constant support. This book reports on the development and validation of a generic defeasible logic programming framework for carrying out. On the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasoning and logic programming and nperson games. In this case, we would do deductions by calculating the probability of the conclusion given the probabilities of the premises. The choice of statecharts and defeasible logic with respect to other formalisms is justi ed against a set of desirable criteria, and their suitability is illustrated through concrete examples of bidding and multilateral bargaining scenarios. Any program written in a logic programming language is a set of sentences in logical form, expressing facts and rules about some problem domain. Education software downloads ladder logic simulator by triangle research international, inc and many more programs are. Education software downloads ladder logic simulator by triangle research international, inc and many more programs are available for instant and free download. Defeasible logic 9,10 is an early approach to sceptical nonmonotonic reasoning. The core system has been shaped to its current form while being used as a tool for building research prototypes, primarily for knowledgeintensive and interactive systems. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Lee a defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications por naeem khalid janjua disponible en rakuten kobo. A defeasible deontic reasoning system based on annotated.
1244 582 464 98 765 1176 1486 973 1010 514 877 277 337 1135 1270 319 806 1055 1179 761 248 384 1489 107 1474 277 839 111 362 325 276 559 552 1279 640 563 1537 202 467 644 694 318 102 1072 581